Drew University Library : University Archives : Theses and Dissertations
    
authorElizabeth M. Freese
titleRite Relations: Toward the Righting of a Misrecognized Moral Order of Re/Production in Hegemonic American Ritual and Myth
abstract This dissertation revisits the classical sociology of religion theory of Max Weber, who contended that a Protestant Ethic of productivity inadvertently spurred a "spirit" of capitalism, which enchants that political-economic system with a social-ethical legitimacy. Taking a materialist feminist approach to ideology critique, I argue that there is significant evidence of ongoing affinity between primary patterns in the capitalist social order — its political-economic and social-ethical dimensions — and a mediating moral order in the ongoing ritual and myth of hegemonic forms of Protestant Christian worship.

In the social and moral orders, the goals and related categories, relations, behaviors, and processes are "homologous," or manifest the same logic, though not obviously or directly so, with both centered upon hyper-re/productivity. Specifically, the Episcopal ritual of Eucharist and the integral myth of Exodus 1-24, woven together within the context of the hierarchical Church, construct a misrecognized moral order of re/production, via metaphors of biological sexual reproduction, which sacralizes and naturalizes ideology that strongly resonates with the social order of capitalist society.

Following an extensive historical materialist review of the social order transition from feudalism to capitalism in Europe and its colonies, I interrogate the parallel development of Protestant Reformation religiosity out of medieval Catholicism. From a synthesis of non-reductive materialist and new materialist, feminist theory, on the one hand, and a deep, anthropological and historical genealogy of re/productive religious symbolism, on the other, I derive a novel bio/social-structural relations hermeneutic. I deploy this lens to identify and describe numerous specific ways the Episcopal Church configures re/productive categories according to a patriarchal, hyper-growth logic in its moral order of "rite relations."

This study is intended to challenge the hegemonic construction of a moral order that legitimates capitalism, but also to support creative transformation of that moral order toward the righting of rite relations that align with counter-hegemonic social and ecological justice. Secondarily, this project develops several theoretical and methodological insights that may be useful to religious and feminist studies more broadly. I conclude with a range of examples of rites that construct right relations.

schoolThe Theological School, Drew University
degreePh.D. (2019)
advisor Kate Ott
committee Laurel Kearns
Heather Elkins
Jan Rehmann
full textEFreese.pdf - requires Drew uLogin